The Japanese Need to Learn to Invest Before It’s Too Late
Forgive experienced international investors for yawning: They’ve heard this one before. The very slogan “from savings to investment” is nearly 20 years old, having been the motto of a 2003 campaign to encourage a shift of assets out of underperforming cash deposits. That campaign was, to say the least, unsuccessful. The number of people holding securities has barely budged in the past two decades. Not even the doubling of Japan’s Topix index during the Abenomics era helped get retail back onboard.
While slightly more of the population seem to think investing is needed, two-thirds still say it’s not…
…and interest in assets outside of cash is growing only slowly.
Most household assets are still in deposits:
These days, Japan’s retail investors feel less influential than ever. References to “Mrs. Watanabe,” the proverbial investing housewife, are growing increasingly rare. Market turmoil makes it an especially tricky time to attract investors who can remember stories of people left holding the bag after Japan’s asset-bubble collapse.
Compare that to neighboring South Korea, where retail investors are so important that the leading candidates in the recent presidential election made electoral promises to woo them. In China, the sway of the individual investor is legendary. While in the US, Robinhood Markets Inc. was the talk of the pandemic as people stuck at home gamified betting on stocks. In Japan, people took to betting on online horse races instead.
It’s not as if Japan’s retirees don’t need to grow their nest eggs: There’s a growing gap between pension payouts and increasing living costs. That’s hardly going to improve as the working population shrinks. But there’s a lack of clarity about government policies. Kishida promises to expand Japan’s system of tax-free investment accounts as well as creating a “new mechanism to encourage citizens to move their savings into asset management.” No one’s quite sure what that means.
There’s a lot of reason to be wary of “this time it’s different” talk in Japan. But one thing really is: inflation. Cash might be a safe option in deflationary times, when spending power increases even if bank accounts yield zero. Inflation, expected to hit 2%, is going to start wearing away that advantage. That will put pressure on Kishida to outline his plans — starting with expanding, and simplifying, arcane tax-free investing accounts. The success of the Furusato Nozei (Hometown Tax) system, which lets residents send part of their taxes to struggling rural municipalities and get gifts of artisanal local produce in return, shows that people can be encouraged with the right incentives.
The man who accidentally received his town’s entire Covid stimulus lost it all at the casino. He says he wants to return it bit by bit over time. Perhaps he should start with some high-yield dividend stocks.
More From This Writer and Others at Bloomberg Opinion:
Workers in Japan Should Ask for a Raise: Gearoid Reidy
Matt Levine’s Money Stuff: Stock Splits Are Good Now
Cathie Wood and the Sound of a Changing Market: Marc Rubinstein
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Gearoid Reidy is a Bloomberg News senior editor covering Japan. He previously led the breaking news team in North Asia and was the Tokyo deputy bureau chief.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion